Indirect and Direct Inguinal Hernias: Causes, Anatomy, Symptoms, Diagnosis, and Treatment
Introduction to Inguinal Hernias
Hernia (a word derived from the Greek, meaning “sprouting
forth”) has been defined, from the time of A. Cornelius Celsus (second century
AD), as a protrusion of an organ or tissue, through an abnormal opening, from
the organ’s natural place in a cavity. Hernias are classified by the cause or
the anatomic location of the defect.
Approximately 75% of hernias occur in the groin
region. Groin hernias are classified as indirect inguinal, direct inguinal,
or femoral hernias based on the site of herniation in relation to the
surrounding structures. An inguinal hernia that has direct and indirect
components is referred to as a pantaloon hernia.
Indirect Inguinal Hernias
Definition and Pathophysiology
An indirect inguinal hernia is the most
common type, irrespective of gender. It is characterized by the propulsion of
the hernia sac through the internal inguinal ring toward the external inguinal
ring and, at times, into the scrotum.
The incidence of inguinal hernias has a bimodal
distribution, with peaks before the first of year of age and after age 60
years. Inguinal hernia is three to four times as frequent in males as in
females, and this fact points to a causative relationship, namely, a
developmental process connected with the descent of the testes in fetal life.
As the testes descend from the intraabdominal space
into the scrotum in the third trimester of pregnancy, they are preceded by the
gubernaculum and a fold of peritoneum, known as the funicular process (see
Plate 2-55) or processus vaginalis. This process is normally obliterated during
the eighth month of intrauterine life, becoming a thin, solid strand of
connective tissue (ligamentum vaginale).
If the process is not obliterated, a peritoneal
pouch or sac termed the patent processus vaginalis persists; this accounts for
the high incidence of indirect inguinal hernias in preterm babies.
Normally, the deep (internal) inguinal ring (see
also pages serves as a perfect closure against the egression of any structure
within the abdominal cavity. If, however, the funicular process is not
obliterated completely, the sac may grow in size or may be the object of
pathologic changes resulting in damage to fascial and muscular elements and
thereby lead to incompetence of the ring.
However, a patent processus vaginalis does not necessarily
indicate an inguinal hernia. Numerous individuals of both sexes have been found
with a patent funicular process without ever having had any signs of a hernia.
Others “acquire” a complete hernia only late in life.
Risk Factors for Indirect Inguinal Hernias
Epidemiologic studies have identified risk factors
that play a role in the formation of a hernia in the presence or absence of a
patent processus vaginalis.
Inherent collagen weakness can predispose to
formation of a hernia. Collagen disorders such as Ehlers-Danlos syndrome are
also associated with an increased incidence of hernia.
A chronic increase in abdominal pressure and
enhanced tension on the wall, as seen in pregnancy or with ascites or chronic
obstructive pulmonary disease, can force abdominal contents through the
inguinal canal.
Alternatively, strenuous physical activity or a
sudden increase in abdominal pressure caused by lifting heavy objects can exert
increased pressure against the abdominal wall, producing a clinically
detectable hernia.
Anatomy of an Indirect Inguinal
Hernia
For the understanding of the cause, clinical
manifestations, and, particularly, surgical repair of an indirect inguinal
hernia, a detailed knowledge of the anatomy of this region is critical. The
anatomy has been illustrated and discussed in Plates 2-1 to 2-3.
In acquired inguinal hernia, the ring
becomes dilated over time or, as in a congenital hernia, is wide enough from
the very start to permit passage of the small or large intestine, omentum, or
bladder.
The size of the sac depends on its contents. It
always lies anterosuperior to the spermatic cord, which contains the ductus
deferens; the testicular, cremasteric, and deferential vessels; the pampiniform
plexus; and the lymphatic vessels and nerves.
The narrow proximal part of the sac, which is
continuous with the parietal peritoneum, is called the “neck” of the sac,
whereas the distal part is known as the “fundus.”
The coverings of the hernial sac are the same as
those of the spermatic cord under normal conditions. The peritoneal innermost
layer is covered by areolar tissue, the internal spermatic (infundibuliform)
fascia derived from the transversalis muscle and the musculofascial cremasteric
layer, essentially derived from the internal oblique muscle and aponeurosis.
In moderate-sized to large indirect inguinal
hernias, the obliqueness of the inguinal canal is mostly lost. With the
widening of the deep (internal, abdominal) ring and the increased masses
filling the canal, the two inguinal rings (deep and superficial) start to lie
more and more perpendicularly above each other.
A medial displacement of the inferior epigastric
vessels is another consequence of this directional shift of the inguinal canal.
Clinical Manifestations of
Indirect Inguinal Hernias
Indirect inguinal hernia may manifest in a range of
clinical scenarios. It may be incidentally detected during physical examination
in an otherwise asymptomatic individual or it can cause a life-threatening
mechanical bowel obstruction with incarceration and strangulation.
Some patients, especially those who are middle-aged
or elderly, may describe pain or discomfort in the lower abdominal quadrants,
or the appearance of a swelling, with some sort of an accident or a specific
event of strain.
The frequency and intensity of pain, however, vary
greatly from individual to individual. In general, chronic moderate or even
extensive protrusion of abdominal contents through an enlarged deep inguinal
ring usually produces, except for cases with incarceration, less discomfort
than do those cases with a sudden onset.
The family history may reveal an increased
incidence of hernia.
Diagnosis of Indirect Inguinal
Hernias
The diagnosis of an uncomplicated indirect inguinal
hernia is made by inspection and palpation.
The patient should be examined in the supine as
well as the erect position, first with the flat hand over the inguinal region
and the fingertips resting over the superficial (subcutaneous) inguinal ring
and exerting a slight pressure along the inguinal canal.
Second, with the palmar surface of the hand resting
over the patient’s thigh, the fifth finger should be gently pushed forward
through the superficial ring invaginating the scrotal skin. The protruding
abdominal tissue can thus be felt while the patient is completely relaxed.
A patent but empty sac cannot be felt and
diagnosed, but requesting the patient to use the abdominal musculature to
increase the abdominal pressure or asking him or her to cough will often be
helpful in discovering the functional incompetence of the deep inguinal ring
and will force a part of the abdominal contents to enter the canal, so that the
palpating finger feels it directly or at least feels a change or shift of the
tissues within the canal.
In infants, the examination is naturally not so
simple, and a hernia, when reduced, is hardly recognizable. Thickening of the
cord at the superficial ring is said to be a reliable sign of a hernia,
provided it is unilateral so that the cord on both sides can be compared.
Children with a left-sided congenital inguinal
hernia have an increased chance of soon revealing one on the other side. Oddly,
this is not true of a right-sided hernia.
Diagnosis in Females
When women are concerned, the best diagnostic
method consists in placing two fingers over the subcutaneous inguinal ring and
palpating for an expansile impulse on coughing or, better, on a more steady
increase of intraabdominal pressure as produced by voluntary contraction of the
abdominal musculature.
Differentiating Indirect and
Direct Inguinal Hernias
Distinction between indirect and direct inguinal
hernias can be made by occluding the internal inguinal ring with a finger as
the patient coughs.
An indirect inguinal hernia should be blocked, but
a direct hernia should freely bulge.
Additionally, transmission of the cough impulse to
the tip of the finger implies an indirect hernia, whereas an impulse palpated
on the dorsum of the finger implies a direct hernia.
These physical findings distinguish between direct
and indirect hernias only 50% of the time.
Differential Diagnosis
If the herniated organ has protruded as far as the
scrotum, consideration must be given to the possibility of other scrotal
swellings, such as a hydrocele, epididymitis, testicular torsion, varicocele,
or even testicular tumors.
In females, labial cysts, abscesses, or tumors
should be considered.
Laboratory Testing and Imaging
Laboratory testing is not helpful in the diagnosis
of inguinal hernias. Incarceration and bowel ischemia may be associated with
nonspecific leukocytosis.
Abdominal imaging is rarely used for diagnosis and
usually helps exclude other causes.
Definition and Pathophysiology
The direct inguinal hernia has an etiologic
and pathologic background quite different from that of the indirect inguinal
hernia.
It is rarely seen in children, and it more
frequently presents at 40 to 50 years of age, with a strong preponderance in
males.
Thus, although considered an acquired disease, it
nevertheless must be traced back to a congenital condition characterized by a
poorly developed musculofascial wall in the lower-most portion of the internal
oblique muscle, where the fibers, instead of coursing obliquely, are arranged
more transversely.
Furthermore, partly as a result of the transverse
course of the fibers, the conjoined tendon is attached to the sheath of the
rectus muscle at a variable distance above the pubic crest.
The predisposing factor of a direct hernia is
thereby assumed to be deficient protection of the inguinal (Hesselbach)
triangle, particularly of its lateral angle.
The characteristic anatomic feature of a direct
inguinal hernia is that it protrudes medial to the inferior epigastric vessels
instead of lateral to them, as with the indirect hernia.
In other words, the direct hernia does not pass
through the deep ring but bulges through the posterior wall of the inguinal
canal.
The precipitating causes may be strenuous and/or
prolonged exertions in the erect position that produce a marked increase in
intraabdominal pressure, or progressive distention of the abdomen as in
ascites, or a progressive atrophy of abdominal muscles owing to advanced age or
a wasting disease.
Clinical Manifestations of Direct
Inguinal Hernias
The clinical manifestations of the direct inguinal
hernia are even less noticeable than are those of the indirect type.
The onset is insidious and asymptomatic. The
patient or the physician may incidentally discover a painless bulge in the
inguinal area.
The mass is reduced instantly when the patient lies
down and can reappear upon arising or with straining.
With an increase in size, though this is uncommon,
the direct inguinal hernia remains in the area above the inguinal ligament,
expanding medially, in contrast to the indirect variety, which, as a rule,
enlarges downward into the scrotum.
Diagnosis of Direct Inguinal
Hernias
The protrusion only rarely emerges from the
subcutaneous ring and usually remains small and incomplete.
The globular mass is found close to the lateral
border of the os pubis, the spermatic cord resting superficially and laterally
upon the protrusion.
With the hernia reduced, the same maneuver outlined
for the diagnosis of indirect hernia (see above) should be carried out.
When the patient coughs, if the impulse is felt by
the index finger as coming from the floor of the canal, pushing the finger
outward, instead of being felt on the tip of the fifth finger as coming from
above downward, the hernia is likely to be of the direct type.
Treatment of Inguinal Hernias
General Treatment Principles
The definitive treatment of indirect inguinal
hernia is surgical repair.
Inguinal hernia repair is among the most common
procedures performed by general surgeons.
Nonoperative management, namely the use of a truss,
can be used for pain, pressure, and protrusion of abdominal contents in the
symptomatic patient who is not able to undergo surgery.
In newborns, the application of a simple yarn truss
for a period of 2 to 6 months is sometimes sufficient to prevent the protrusion
of the abdominal contents and to allow for the spontaneous closure of a
funicular process not obliterated at birth, but this method is not used much
today, and surgical repair is preferred at any age.
Surgical Treatment in Infants
The surgical treatment of an inguinal hernia in
infants is relatively simple and can be expeditiously accomplished in a matter
of minutes, especially when the hernia is small and of recent onset.
Ligation and excision of the sac is all that is
required, because in infants the deep inguinal ring is almost adjacent to the
superficial ring, and it is not necessary to divide the external oblique
aponeurosis.
Surgical intervention is urgently required in infants
with an extroverted urinary bladder; an undescended testis, with or without
torsion; or an ectopic testis.
In girls, the presence of the ovary, fallopian
tube, or uterus in the hernia sac must be ruled out before ligation.
Open Surgical Repair of Inguinal
Hernias
Surgical repair of indirect inguinal hernias in
adults can be performed using an open or laparoscopic approach.
Modern surgery of inguinal hernias began about 70
years ago, when Bassini (in Padua, Italy) and Halsted (in Baltimore, Maryland)
simultaneously and independently developed operative techniques, the
fundamental principles of which were identification and excision of the
persistent sac, reparation of the defective deep ring, and strengthening of the
posterior wall of the inguinal canal.
Whether open or laparoscopic, successful hernia
repair depends on a tension-free closure that can be achieved either with a
primary approximation or with the use of a mesh.
Open repair is generally indicated for strangulated
or large inguinal hernias or in cases where there is ascites or previous pelvic
surgery.
The open approach is also preferred for repair of
unilateral inguinal hernias in men.
If the open approach is planned, the use of
tension-free mesh has to be considered.
The use of mesh generally reduces recurrence, but
the risk of infection is increased if the hernia is complicated by
incarceration or strangulation.
Common Open Mesh Repair
Techniques
The most common open mesh repair techniques used
are the Lichtenstein repair and the “plug and patch” repair.
Open Repair Without Mesh
When the mesh cannot be used, as in wound
infection, primary approximation can be achieved using traditional open
techniques such as the Bassini, Shouldice, and McVay repairs.
Laparoscopic Repair of Inguinal
Hernias
Laparoscopic hernia repair is increasingly popular,
and under expert hands, recurrence rates are low.
In the absence of the contraindications listed
above, the laparoscopic approach is minimally invasive, with less postoperative
pain and a fast recovery time.
The two most commonly performed laparoscopic
inguinal hernia repair techniques are the transabdominal preperitoneal hernia
repair and the totally extraperitoneal hernia repair approaches.
The use of mesh to create a tension-free repair is
recommended for all laparoscopic techniques; a preformed mesh that conforms to
the space is available.
Fixation of the mesh is recommended to avoid mesh
migration and shrinkage, although care must be taken to avoid inadvertent nerve
injury.
The choice of which laparoscopic technique to use
mainly depends on the expertise of the surgeon.
The totally extraperitoneal hernia repair technique
is generally recommended for male patients, whereas in women with indirect
inguinal hernias or individuals who have undergone prior pelvic surgery, the
transabdominal preperitoneal hernia repair approach offers an easier and safer
method.



